JC or Enchanting

FireFly · **Posted:** Sat Oct 03, 2009 7:33 pm

I'm trying to decide if I want to drop herbalism in exchange for JC or Enchanting. Money is good with Herbalism but I think I'll be a better mage with JC or Enchanting. What do you guys think?

I have a druid and a priest for alts so those are options as well and my warlock is already herbalism but shes on another realm. :banghead:

I'll check back here later on tonight...ty. :love:

[SD]Master_Wong · **Posted:** Sat Oct 03, 2009 11:03 pm

well both can bring a lot of gold in done right

personally i think id go enchanting seeing as it tends to be cheaper atm to make high end enchants and put them on valium rather then get the new gems

[TS]=Hark=[TS] · **Posted:** Mon Oct 05, 2009 5:06 pm

"what will make you a better mage"? JC, enchanting = 23 spellpower enchant on your rings, JC = 3 epic gems that are better then the epic gems you can buy.

Lempi · **Joined:** Oct 2008 **Posts:** 3203 **Location:** England

[TS]=Hark=[TS] wrote:

"what will make you a better mage"? JC, enchanting = 23 spellpower enchant on your rings, JC = 3 epic gems that are better then the epic gems you can buy.

Yes but you need to consider, are the epic gems better than the extra 46 spell power, not the mention the ability to make alot of gold from disenchanting and selling the materials.

cuchulainn · **Joined:** Apr 2006 **Posts:** 2168 **Location:**

Lempi wrote:

[TS]=Hark=[TS] wrote:

"what will make you a better mage"? JC, enchanting = 23 spellpower enchant on your rings, JC = 3 epic gems that are better then the epic gems you can buy.

Yes but you need to consider, are the epic gems better than the extra 46 spell power, not the mention the ability to make alot of gold from disenchanting and selling the materials.

JC+Enchanting
or
JC+Blacksmithing

These 2 combos give the best possible stat upgrade raiding-wise. The question was "what will make me a better mage" not "what will make me the best moneymaker"

takolin · **Joined:** Jan 2007 **Posts:** 4238 **Location:** Life

cuchulainn wrote:

Lempi wrote:

[TS]=Hark=[TS] wrote:

"what will make you a better mage"? JC, enchanting = 23 spellpower enchant on your rings, JC = 3 epic gems that are better then the epic gems you can buy.

Yes but you need to consider, are the epic gems better than the extra 46 spell power, not the mention the ability to make alot of gold from disenchanting and selling the materials.

JC+Enchanting
or
JC+Blacksmithing

These 2 combos give the best possible stat upgrade raiding-wise. The question was "what will make me a better mage" not "what will make me the best moneymaker"

For raiding tailoring is king for a caster unless the downtime of the lightweave embroidery is a huge issue.

For a mage alchemy, JC, BS, inscription, enchanting all offer an equal bonus with a difference of 1-2 SP thus it won't matter.

Certain classes have more benefit from JC/BS because better gems give a better advantage than straight AP.

iGod · **Joined:** Oct 2006 **Posts:** 3728 **Location:**

cuchulainn wrote:

Lempi wrote:

[TS]=Hark=[TS] wrote:

"what will make you a better mage"? JC, enchanting = 23 spellpower enchant on your rings, JC = 3 epic gems that are better then the epic gems you can buy.

Yes but you need to consider, are the epic gems better than the extra 46 spell power, not the mention the ability to make alot of gold from disenchanting and selling the materials.

JC+Enchanting
or
JC+Blacksmithing

These 2 combos give the best possible stat upgrade raiding-wise. The question was "what will make me a better mage" not "what will make me the best moneymaker"

+1

wtb str ring enchant :/

[TS]=Hark=[TS] · **Posted:** Mon Oct 05, 2009 10:19 pm

yes +20 str to rings plys!

jc+enchanting is a nice combo... thats what i am.

[SD]Master_Wong · **Posted:** Tue Oct 06, 2009 1:31 am

iv always been mining/jc and theres a lot of money to be made there, an hour farming saronite and titanium ore gives a lot of gold (prospect it all ofc)

enchanting on the other hand you can get rid of all the blue, green and purple junk and make a profit out of it

everything can make money minus engineering

[TS]=Hark=[TS] · **Posted:** Tue Oct 06, 2009 2:14 am

[SD]Master_Wong wrote:

iv always been mining/jc and theres a lot of money to be made there, an hour farming saronite and titanium ore gives a lot of gold (prospect it all ofc)

enchanting on the other hand you can get rid of all the blue, green and purple junk and make a profit out of it

everything can make money minus engineering

ive never sold an abyss crystal yet... enchanting doesnt make me any money.

[SD]Master_Wong · **Posted:** Tue Oct 06, 2009 2:34 am

[TS]=Hark=[TS] wrote:

[SD]Master_Wong wrote:

iv always been mining/jc and theres a lot of money to be made there, an hour farming saronite and titanium ore gives a lot of gold (prospect it all ofc)

enchanting on the other hand you can get rid of all the blue, green and purple junk and make a profit out of it

everything can make money minus engineering

ive never sold an abyss crystal yet... enchanting doesnt make me any money.

haha you fail really bad

im making about 5k a week from enchanting mats alone on a good week that is but on a bad one im stil making 2k then count in other things i sell, and im not even an enchanter if i could de my own shit efficiently i would be making a hell of a lot more

how on earth your not making gold is beyond me, done believe me or doubt what im saying il link you my armory so you can check out the achieve for my 16k gold mount xD mechanohog was delayed until i renew my subscription

[TS]=Hark=[TS] · **Posted:** Tue Oct 06, 2009 3:25 am

well i have 45 abyss crystals sitting in my bank that sell for about 5g each so im saving them. not worth it right now. and i never get infinite dusts because i get mabey 1 green drop a week and its usually a cosmic essence.

Necrobat · **Posted:** Tue Oct 06, 2009 3:57 am

Wait, Abyss sells for 5g on your server? O_o They're like, 50-70g on the AH on mine.

[TS]=Hark=[TS] · **Posted:** Tue Oct 06, 2009 5:07 am

yeah they are worthless. you get so many from regular toc.

[SD]Master_Wong · **Posted:** Tue Oct 06, 2009 11:08 am

my server

infinite dust - 5-6g
greater cosmic essence - 25g~
dream shard - 25g~
abyss crystal - 35g~

and you dont make money from the greens that drop you buy out all the cheap greens in ah or buy and sell cheap infinite dust or greater cosmic essence, besides if your abyss crystals are so cheap just use that new enchanting thing

[TS]=Hark=[TS] · **Posted:** Tue Oct 06, 2009 12:13 pm

[SD]Master_Wong wrote:

my server

infinite dust - 5-6g
greater cosmic essence - 25g~
dream shard - 25g~
abyss crystal - 35g~

and you dont make money from the greens that drop you buy out all the cheap greens in ah or buy and sell cheap infinite dust or greater cosmic essence, besides if your abyss crystals are so cheap just use that new enchanting thing

what new enchanting thing?

and infinite dust is really high, 250g a stack on my server. greater cosmics i havnt checked in a while but it was about 30g each about two weeks ago

bakafish · **Posted:** Tue Oct 06, 2009 3:28 pm

Abyssal Shatter.

Silkroad Online Forums

JC or Enchanting

Who is online