I'm just going to argue the point
Lets just say it all depends on the buffs, weapons. An 80 Archer Vs an 80 Rogue the Rogue no doubt!
But if they were both buffed I think it would be a good match! I mean if bow got first hit that is!
Knock-back high crit. Over 40k HP (cleric!)
Rogue same health but slower potting!